Are American Pit Bull Terriers and American Staffordshire Terriers the Same?

When it comes to the American Pit Bull Terrier vs American Staffordshire Terrier debate, the lines can get a bit blurry. These two breeds share a lot of similarities, but there are also some key differences that set them apart.

American Pit Bull Terriers vsAmerican Staffordshire Terriers

First, let’s address the elephant in the room – yes, they are essentially the same breed with the same ancestors. The American Pit Bull Terrier and American Staffordshire Terrier both descended from the Staffordshire Bull Terrier, which was brought to the United States from England in the 19th century. However, they diverged into separate breeds due to a split in the registry organizations.

Historical Background

To understand the nuances of these breeds, it’s essential to consider their origins. The American Pit Bull Terrier (APBT) and the American Staffordshire Terrier (AmStaff) share common ancestors. Both breeds can trace their lineage back to the 19th century when bulldogs and terriers were crossbred in England for bull-baiting and later for dog fighting.

The distinction between the two began to take shape in the early 20th century. The APBT was bred for its fighting ability and later recognized by the United Kennel Club (UKC) in 1898. Conversely, breeders of the American Staffordshire Terrier aimed for a more refined dog, focusing on appearance and temperament, leading to its recognition by the American Kennel Club (AKC) in 1936.

Physical Appearance

American Pit Bull Terriers vsAmerican Staffordshire Terriers

At first glance, the American Pit Bull Terrier and the American Staffordshire Terrier look quite similar. Both breeds have a muscular build, short coat, and a broad head. However, there are subtle differences.

The American Pit Bull Terrier vs. American Staffordshire Terrier comparison often highlights size and build. APBTs tend to be slightly taller and leaner, typically standing 17 to 21 inches tall and weighing between 30 and 60 pounds. They have a more athletic build, reflecting their history as working dogs.

On the other hand, AmStaffs are generally shorter and stockier. They stand 17 to 19 inches tall and weigh between 40 and 70 pounds. Their build is more compact and solid, giving them a robust appearance.

Lots of Confusion

However, when you talk to people who have worked with both even they have a hard time telling them apart and feel like the distinction is marketing.

I’ve found that those two breeds are basically identical in all but name.

Reddit User PathoftheWolf

“I’ve found that those two breeds are basically identical in all but name. But there are occasionally some owners of either breed that get really, really upset if you mistake their breed for the other,” said reddit user PathoftheWolf,

“AmStaffs can be dual registered as American pit bull terriers. Europeans didn’t want their beloved English Staffordshire Bull Terrier to be confused with the AmStaff hence in the UK they’re registered as American Pit Bull Terriers to avoid confusion,” according to SHIPPO999

American Pit Bull Terriers vsAmerican Staffordshire Terriers
American Pit Bull Terrier (left) vs. American Staffordshire Terrier (right)

Shelter Labeling and Public Perception

There is also inconsistency in labeling these breeds, particularly in shelters. In the US, many dogs in the bully breed category are labeled as pit bulls, whereas in Australia, similar dogs are often called staffies. This inconsistency can lead to public confusion and misidentification, impacting breed perceptions and adoption rates.

What do DNA Tests Say

DNA tests can distinguish between American Staffordshire Terriers (AmStaffs) and American Pit Bull Terriers (APBTs) based on their genetic profiles and breed markers. Here are some key points on how this works:

  • Companies like Embark and Wisdom Panel have built extensive breed databases that include distinct genetic signatures for AmStaffs and APBTs.
  • While the two breeds share ancestry and physical similarities, their gene pools have diverged over time due to different breeding goals and closed studbooks.
  • Embark and Wisdom Panel analyze hundreds of thousands of genetic markers across a dog’s DNA to identify breed signatures and percentages.
  • For purebred dogs, they can definitively determine if a dog is an AmStaff or APBT based on matching the breed-specific markers.
  • For mixed breeds, they can detect the percentages of AmStaff and APBT ancestry present and report them separately.
  • Wisdom Panel sometimes reports pure APBTs as around 90% APBT and 10% AmStaff/Boxer, reflecting the close ancestral ties between these breeds.

While AmStaffs and APBTs may look very similar, modern DNA tests can reliably tease apart their genetic distinctions and ancestry percentages, providing a scientific way to differentiate between these two closely related but distinct breeds.

Temperament and Behavior

Understanding the temperament of these breeds is crucial, especially for families and individuals looking to adopt. The pit bull vs. American Staffordshire Terrier debate often centers on their behavior and interaction with humans and other animals.

American Pit Bull Terriers are known for their high energy, intelligence, and loyalty. They are often described as affectionate and eager to please, making them excellent companions. However, their high energy levels require regular exercise and mental stimulation to prevent boredom and destructive behavior.

American Pit Bull Terriers vsAmerican Staffordshire Terriers
American Pit Bull Terrier

American Staffordshire Terriers, while also loyal and affectionate, are often perceived as more stable and manageable. They are known for their friendly disposition towards people, including strangers, and their patience with children. However, like APBTs, they require proper socialization and training from an early age to ensure they grow into well-rounded dogs.

American Pit Bull Terriers vsAmerican Staffordshire Terriers
American Staffordshire Terriers

Training and Socialization

Both breeds benefit significantly from early socialization and consistent training. Given their strong-willed nature, it’s essential to establish a positive and structured environment.

American Pit Bull Terriers are highly trainable due to their intelligence and eagerness to please. Positive reinforcement methods work best, and early socialization helps them develop into friendly and confident dogs.

American Staffordshire Terriers also respond well to positive reinforcement training. Their slightly calmer demeanor might make them appear easier to train, but consistency and patience are key with both breeds.

Health and Lifespan

When comparing the American Staffordshire Terrier vs. American Pit Bull Terrier, their health and lifespan are important considerations.

Both breeds are generally healthy but can be prone to certain genetic conditions. American Pit Bull Terriers may face issues such as hip dysplasia, allergies, and certain heart conditions. Regular veterinary check-ups and a balanced diet can help mitigate these risks.

American Staffordshire Terriers share similar health concerns, including hip dysplasia and certain skin conditions. Responsible breeding practices and regular health screenings are crucial to maintaining their health.

In terms of lifespan, both breeds typically live between 12 to 16 years, provided they receive proper care, nutrition, and regular veterinary attention.

American Pit Bull Terriers vsAmerican Staffordshire Terriers


In the American Pit Bull Terrier vs. American Staffordshire Terrier comparison, it’s clear that while they share a common ancestry and many similarities, there are distinct differences in their physical appearance, temperament, and health.

Choosing between these breeds depends largely on your lifestyle, experience with dogs, and personal preferences. Both the APBT and the AmStaff can make loving and loyal companions with the right training, socialization, and care. Whether you’re drawn to the athleticism and energy of the American Pit Bull Terrier or the robust and friendly nature of the American Staffordshire Terrier, understanding these differences will help you make an informed decision.

Ultimately, the debate of pit bull vs. American Staffordshire Terrier highlights the importance of recognizing each dog’s unique traits and needs. By appreciating their distinct qualities, potential owners can ensure a harmonious and fulfilling relationship with their chosen breed.

Top Rated Dog Treats Every Dog Will Love

Jerky - Made in USA

Good Dog Chews