Which Indoor Doggy Solution Is Best: Bark Potty or Doggie Lawn?
Do you ever find yourself wishing there was a patch of grass where your pup could go potty in your home? Maybe you live somewhere with long, cold winters that make going out nearly impossible. Maybe you live in an apartment complex on the 15th floor, or it’s hard to find a good potty spot in your city setting. Maybe you have a senior dog who needs to go outside more often than they used to, and you’re struggling to keep up.
Basically—wouldn’t it be nice to not have to leash up and go outside every time your pooch needs a quick potty break?
Introducing indoor lawns! Small, self-contained patches of grass or dirt that fit perfectly into the corner of your home and are ready for use any time your pup needs to pee. Think of them as the new and improved potty pad! Genius, right?
We’re comparing two of the best on the market: Bark Potty and the Doggie Lawn. Each one is an excellent balcony dog potty but how they accomplish their goal varies. We’re putting these two products head-to-head to see which option performs best, which comes at the best price, and whether either one stands above the other as the ultimate indoor potty lawn.
Side-By-Side Comparison of Bark Potty vs. Doggie Lawn
You’ve never used pee pads like this before! These two indoor potty spots are designed to reinforce your dog’s natural instinct to go pee outside, while still giving your pooch an option indoors. What makes this alternative to pee pads even better is you don’t need to train your dog how to bark to go potty, ring a bell, or lead you to the door. They can just go when they need to!
Less smelly, better for the environment, and considerably more aesthetically pleasing than standard puppy pads, either of these options is a major upgrade, but which is right for you?
| Bark Potty | Doggie Lawn | |
| Base Price | $37.00 | $33.35 |
| Measurements & Sizes | Standard: 16 x 24”Large: 20 x 30” | Standard: 16 x 24”Medium: 20 x 24”Large: 24 x 24”Extra-Large: 24 x 48” |
| Substrate | Natural wood bark blend | Grass |
| Odor-Free | Yes | Yes |
| Refillable | No, disposable only | Yes, disposable also available |
| Subscription Available | Yes | Yes |
| Unit Lifespan | Up to 30 days | Up to 30 days |
Bark Potty
Bark Potty features a unique, simple design, but highly functional design that makes potty breaks easy for both you and your pup. Each Bark Potty tray comes in a recyclable tray and is filled with a proprietary blend of wood bark that naturally keeps odors at bay and attracts your pup with its earthy scent. To keep the bark from going everywhere, each Bark Potty also features a lightweight mesh covering. One of the best features of the Bark Potty is the built-in roll of poop bags!
Bark Potty comes in two sizes—standard for small and medium dogs, and large for medium to large dogs. Each potty lasts approximately a month with regular use and is made from fully recyclable materials.
| Pros | Cons |
| Recyclable | Not real grass |
| Great for travel | Disposable only, no refills |
| Lightweight | |
| Odor-free |
DoggieLawn
Doggie Lawn is a real grass potty pad you can keep inside! Available in four sizes and both refillable and disposable tray options, this is our most versatile pick. Each Doggie Lawn includes a tray to catch anything that passes through the grass and a sheet of hydroponic sod that offers all the benefits of grass with no dirt, mud, or mess. Purchase a full tray, or buy just the sod refill to refresh the grass once a month.
Virtually odor free, you’ll know it’s time for new grass because your pup stops wanting to use their Doggie Lawn, not because it starts to smell. Even though it’s real grass, Doggie Lawn doesn’t need watering unless you live in an extremely hot or dry climate—just find a spot to put it indoors and let your pup enjoy the convenient potty.
| Pros | Cons |
| Real grass | Heavy |
| Refillable | May require light watering |
| 4 sizes available | |
| Odor-free | |
| Doggie Lawn discount codes regularly available |
Which Indoor Potty Lawn Is Better?
When you look at these two products on the outside, they might seem pretty similar, but you’ll find there are significant differences that make one superior to the other—at least in certain circumstances. Let’s take a look at some key categories of comparison between Bark Potty and Doggie Lawn to determine which is better once and for all.
| Price | Doggie Lawn is cheaper overall than Bark Potty if you compare the standard sizes. Bark Potty is $37 for a 24 x 16-inch potty, whereas Doggie Lawn is $33. ???? Winner: Doggie Lawn |
| Lifespan | Both Doggie Lawn and Bark Potty can last up to a month, assuming your dog isn’t using their indoor pee spot for every potty break. If your dog is using their indoor potty for all potty breaks, Bark Potty will last longer before needing to be replaced. ???? Winner: Bark Potty |
| Odor control | Both Doggie Lawn and Bark Potty are considered odor-free options, but Bark Potty will stay odor-free longer thanks to the proprietary blend of naturally deodorizing bark. ???? Winner: Bark Potty |
| Sizing | Doggie Lawn has more sizing options than Bark Potty, and makes it possible to combine units to make larger potty spots for extra-large dogs. ???? Winner: Doggie Lawn |
| Portability | If you’re looking for an alternative to potty pads while you travel with your dog, Bark Potty is the more lightweight option and better for short-term usage. ???? Winner: Bark Potty |
| Durability | If you have a dog who likes to dig, chew, and destroy, Bark Potty is the more durable option. Made from coated cardboard and bark held in with a mesh webbing, the Bark Potty can withstand a little bit of chewing, and won’t motivate your dog to dig as much as a real grass option like Doggie Lawn. ???? Winner: Bark Potty |
| Convenience | Set up is equally easy for Bark Potty and Doggie Lawn alike, and both brands offer disposable options. If you don’t want to dispose of the tray every time, Doggie Lawn offers convenient refills so you can just replace the grass. Doggie Lawn also sends you a free bag to dispose of your old lawn. ???? Winner: Doggie Lawn |
| Environment | Both of these products are eco-friend and made from all-natural, fully biodegradable materials. While either option is better for the environment than puppy pads, DoggieLawn is the most environmentally-friendly option thanks to the brand’s commitment to low-water usage and supporting local farms. ???? Winner: Doggie Lawn |
| Customer Experience | Bark Potty has the better subscription service of these two options, and allows customers to skip, pause, delay, or cancel deliveries at any time. Doggie Lawn locks you into a three-shipment minimum immediately, and won’t allow you to cancel already-scheduled shipments. ???? Winner: Bark Potty |
Bark Potty Reviews
To help you make the right choice for your dog’s needs, let’s take a look at some reviews from users of both types of potty: Bark Potty and Doggie Lawn!
Reviews of the Bark Potty are overwhelmingly positive, and what most pet owners love most is how easy it is to set up, use, and forget about! No more worrying all day about your dog’s bladder—the Bark Potty doesn’t look like much, but it’s so, so useful when your pooch needs to go.
“There’s no smell and it’s visually unobtrusive. We no longer have to use the regular (and ugly) potty pads that have to be discarded after one use.”
A reviewer
Users of Bark Potty also love how versatile the product is. This isn’t just for home—Bark Potty is a nice solution for potty breaks on the road and while traveling, too.
“We took [Bark Potty] traveling and it was perfect for the hotel room”
A Costumer
This reviewer fell in love with the Bark Potty after taking it on vacation for their puppy.
“Will be using it to keep pop from being in the yard where the kiddos play!”
Another Reviewer
Doggie Lawn Reviews
Like reviews for Bark Potty, reviews for Doggie Lawn show happy, satisfied customers! Doggie Lawn has become a key component of life for many dog owners, and many get peace of mind from this product.
“My Chihuahua Yorkie mix is 10 years old and the grass is very convenient when she needs to potty while I’m at work and for the middle of the night. We have coyotes in my area so taking her outside in the middle of the night was not safe.”
A Reviewer
As convenient as products like Doggie Lawn are for dogs, they can also be integral tools for people with limited mobility.
“I don’t have a balcony or yard and it’s hard for me to go down the stairs every 2 hours, so I use it as a back-up and it’s amazing”
Another Reviewer
Thank goodness for tools like this that make it possible for anyone to have a dog.
Why Use an Indoor Doggy Potty?
Wondering why it could be worth it to have an indoor potty spot for your pooch? After all, it’s not normal for dogs to go to the bathroom inside, but think of all the reasons an indoor pee spot could be convenient for you, your dog, or others.
The most obvious benefit of owning an indoor doggy potty is convenience. Your dog doesn’t have to wait or ask to go outside, which means they can go potty whether or not you are home, awake, or available. This also makes these products a good option for people who work from home or are extremely busy during parts of the day.
For individuals with limited mobility or dogs with disabilities, indoor potty spots can be the thing that makes dog ownership possible. With an indoor potty pad, you don’t need to be able to do stairs, go on multiple walks per day, or force your senior pet to hobble out every time they need a potty break.
Similarly, if you live in a condo, apartment, or another housing option without an easily accessible fenced-in yard, an indoor potty spot can reduce the number of trips you take daily. During cold or wet weather, your dog doesn’t need to suffer getting wet or chilly, and you won’t need to worry about them going on poop strike and holding it until the weather clears up.
Other Indoor Doggy Potty Options
Bark Potty and Doggie Lawn are easily the best indoor potty spot options by our estimation, but there are other products available if you’re not convinced. Here are two alternative options for you to consider.
Fresh Patch
Like Doggie Lawn, Fresh Patch is a real-grass potty spot for your home contained in a simple tray system. A little more expensive than Doggie Lawn, this option also comes in four sizes and is hydroponically grown to eliminate the need for dirt.
Gotta Go Grass
Gotta Go Grass is another real-grass indoor dog potty, but this option includes soil. If you’ve got a dog who likes to dig, they’re guaranteed to make a mess with Gotta Go Grass. Otherwise, this product works similarly to the others featured here but doesn’t have the best reviews comparatively.
FAQ – Bark Potty vs. Doggie Lawn Doggy Potty
What is Bark Potty and how does it work?
Bark Potty is an indoor potty for dogs that uses natural bark to absorb urine and neutralize odors. The bark is contained in a tray that is lined to prevent leaks and can be easily disposed of when needed. Bark Potty is ideal for apartment dwellers, busy owners, or dogs with limited outdoor access.
What is Doggie Lawn and how does it work?
Doggie Lawn is an indoor potty for dogs that uses real grass to mimic the outdoor environment. The grass is delivered fresh to your door and can last up to four weeks with proper care. Doggie Lawn is perfect for dogs who prefer the natural feel and smell of grass.
How do I choose between Bark Potty and Doggie Lawn?
The choice between Bark Potty and Doggie Lawn depends on your personal preference, budget, and space. Bark Potty is more affordable, compact, and durable than Doggie Lawn, but some dogs may not like the texture or scent of bark. Doggie Lawn is more expensive, bulky, and biodegradable than Bark Potty, but some dogs may find it more comfortable and familiar.
How do I use coupon codes or promo codes for Bark Potty or Doggie Lawn?
You can use coupon codes or promo codes for Bark Potty or Doggie Lawn to save money on your orders. Simply enter the code at checkout and enjoy the discount. You can find coupon codes or promo codes for Bark Potty or Doggie Lawn on their official websites, social media pages, newsletters, or online platforms.
How do I potty train my dog using Bark Potty or Doggie Lawn?
You can potty train your dog using Bark Potty or Doggie Lawn by following these steps:
– Place the indoor potty in a designated area that is accessible and convenient for your dog.
– Introduce your dog to the indoor potty and let them sniff and explore it.
– Reward your dog with praise, treats, or toys when they use the indoor potty correctly.
– Repeat the process until your dog associates the indoor potty with their bathroom needs.
– Gradually reduce the rewards and increase the intervals between potty breaks until your dog is fully trained.
How do I clean and maintain Bark Potty or Doggie Lawn?
You can clean and maintain Bark Potty or Doggie Lawn by following these tips:
– For Bark Potty, remove any solid waste daily and spray the tray with water or a mild cleaner to keep it fresh. Replace the tray every two to four weeks or as needed.
– For Doggie Lawn, remove any solid waste daily and water the grass every few days to keep it moist. Replace the grass every two to four weeks or as needed.
– Dispose of the used trays or grass in an eco-friendly way according to local regulations.
How do I teach my dog to use both Bark Potty and Doggie Lawn?
You can teach your dog to use both Bark Potty and Doggie Lawn by following these steps:
– Place both indoor potties in different areas of your home that are accessible and convenient for your dog.
– Introduce your dog to both indoor potties and let them sniff and explore them.
– Reward your dog with praise, treats, or toys when they use either indoor potty correctly.
– Repeat the process until your dog associates both indoor potties with their bathroom needs.
– Gradually reduce the rewards and increase the intervals between potty breaks until your dog is fully trained.
What are the benefits of using Bark Potty or Doggie Lawn over other indoor potties?
The benefits of using Bark Potty or Doggie Lawn over other indoor potties are:
– They are more natural and eco-friendly than synthetic grass, pee pads, or litter boxes.
– They are more sanitary and odorless than synthetic grass, pee pads, or litter boxes.
– They are more convenient and cost-effective than synthetic grass, pee pads, or litter boxes.
– They are more attractive and appealing than synthetic grass, pee pads, or litter boxes.
Q: What are the drawbacks of using Bark Potty or Doggie Lawn over other indoor potties?
A: The drawbacks of using Bark Potty or Doggie Lawn over other indoor potties are:
– They may not be suitable for dogs with allergies or sensitivities to bark or grass.
– They may not be available in all areas or seasons.
– They may require more space and care than synthetic grass, pee pads, or litter boxes.
Where can I buy Bark Potty or Doggie Lawn?
You can buy Bark Potty or Doggie Lawn online from their official websites. You can also find them in some pet stores or online retailers. You can enjoy free shipping on your orders from their official websites. You can also use coupon codes or promo codes to get discounts on your orders.
Are there any concerns about leaks with these solutions?
Both Bark Potty and Doggie Lawn are designed to prevent leaks. Bark Potty’s proprietary bark naturally neutralizes odors and prevents leaks, while Doggie Lawn’s lined tray helps contain any moisture.
Related Posts:
- Would You Sleep in Human Dog Bed?
- The Best Enzyme Cleaner for Dog Urine Rated
- Cheap vs. Expensive Dog Toys: Do Pricey Toys Make Dogs Happier?
- What is the Best Raw Dog Food Delivery Service? The Top 6 Rated & Compared
- Top 9 Best Wooden Chew Toys for Dogs
Read This Next
